Over the past few weeks I recorded 34 conversations for Substack Success Summit.
The creators were at very different stages. Some started with under 100 subscribers. Some now have hundreds of thousands. Some run paid memberships, some sell services, and some host podcasts.
I expected 34 different playbooks. Instead, if I were starting a Substack from zero today, these are the 6 things I’d do.
One came up again and again: collaboration. Many of the fastest-growth stories I heard involved other creators somewhere along the way. That section is the longest one below.
Here’s that plan, in the creators’ own words.
1. Get clear, then keep showing up
The creators who grew could say what they do in one line. Then they kept publishing long enough for it to work.
“Really get clear on your golden thread by figuring out what it is that you do uniquely in the world.”
Lucinda Rae · Find Your Golden Thread: Turn Many Interests Into One Clear Substack Promise
“You have to say what you do and then do what you say.”
Jo Hutton · Say What You Do, Do What You Say: A Simple Marketing System That Builds Trust
“Be clear. Talk about who you help, who’s your best reader and your credentials.”
Matt Giaro · Your First Substack: Set Up Your Publication, Publish Your First Post and Find Your Feet
“You don’t have to know everything, you just need to know something.”
Derek Hughes · Write From an Angle, Not a Topic: Create Substack Posts People Share and Reply To
“You should write the newsletter that you want to read.”
Chris Danton · Connect the Dots: Why Following Your Curiosity Beats Niching Down
“Don’t even stress about more than one platform. Start with Substack, master Substack.”
Aakash Gupta · Run Your Newsletter Like a Product: Free vs Paid, Paywalls and the Metrics That Matter
“Write a post every week, make it good, tell people about it, and give them a reason to pay you.”
Karen Cherry · Slow, Steady, Bestseller: A Five-Step System to Grow a Niche Substack
“Once you have ten thousand email subscribers, life gets a little bit easier, your flywheel starts to get rolling.”
Compounding Quality · Build Your Organic Subscriber Flywheel: Choose Where to Focus Your Growth Effort
2. Your voice is the part AI can’t copy
Content is getting easier to produce. Trust isn’t. Several creators said the human parts of their work, their voice, their face and their honesty about numbers, are what readers come back for.
“Texture itself is like your secret sauce. It’s the thing that makes a Substack either successful or completely skippable.”
Anna Seirian · The Power of Texture: How to Make Your Substack Sound Unmistakably Like You
“Building trust is harder than ever before, thanks to AI.”
Philip Hofmacher · Give Every Format a Job: Build Trust Across Posts, Notes, Lives and DMs
“If you overstate what the data actually gives away, you lose a lot of trust.”
Kevin Indig · One Original Study, Many New Readers: Turn Research Into a Substack Growth Engine
“I’m a human and this doesn’t have to be perfect.”
Carla Contreras · Add Your Voice: Use Audio to Deepen Engagement on Substack
“People do business with people they like, know, and trust. What better way than a little podcast on Substack?”
Blair Kaplan Venables · Podcasting on Substack: How to Set Up, Promote and Grow Your Show
“People will forgive bad video, but they won’t forgive bad audio.”
Jim Fuhs · Go Live, Then Keep Growing: Turn One Substack Live Into a Content Library
3. Substack is a conversation
Notes, comments and chat are where people find you. Carrie Loranger told me that at one point Notes brought in 60% of her new subscribers.
“I like to think about the notes feed as a cocktail party.”
Tracy Friedlander · People Like Us: Write Substack Notes That Start Conversations With the Right Readers
“I like looking at notes like little ads that you put out on Substack.”
Orel · Batch a Week of Notes in One Sitting: A Data-Backed Notes System
“On Instagram people react with emojis, but I feel on Substack people almost leave their mini essays under your work.”
sydney rheeder 𖣠 · Depth Over Frequency: Build a Substack Worth Waiting For
4. Other creators are partners, not competition

This is the one I heard most often.
Guest posts, Lives, interviews, recommendations, podcast spots, chats. The formats changed from creator to creator. The pattern didn’t: the creators who grew fastest often did it alongside other creators. And one collaboration usually led to the next.
“On Substack other creators are not your competition. They are your collaborators, they are your partners.”
Ciler from Newsletter Circle · Interview Your Way Into New Audiences: Build Substack Relationships That Keep Working
She built Newsletter Circle on interviews with other creators. One guest post brought her about 150 subscribers in a single day.
“You’re gonna get so much further in a community than trying to do this in an island all by yourself.”
Joel Salinas · Your First Creator Circle: Grow Faster by Collaborating With Smaller Substacks
At 50 to 100 subscribers, he asked other creators to write guest posts for him. 6 of the first 7 he reached out to are now Substack bestsellers.
“Be the writer that others can’t stop recommending.”
Kristina God · Earn the Recommendation: Build a Substack Partner Network That Brings New Readers
Her practical tip: direct messages, which she calls “the superpower most people don’t use.”
“You show up first to serve before you ever offer dessert.”
Jen Rogers🎤︎︎Mic Drop Mastery · Collaborations That Pay: Find the Right Partners and Turn Conversations Into Clients
Her point: when you leave a good impression on a Live or a guest spot, people refer you to the next host.
“Lives tend to either come off the back of a previous collaboration or lead to another one. It kind of keeps that relationship growing and building.”
David McIlroy · Go Live With Confidence: An Introvert’s Guide to Substack Live
A guest post for someone’s publication can lead to a Live for their audience, and the other way round.
“That’s where I meet people and really connect with them and find collaborators and people to do lives with. That’s where the best relationships are formed.”
Carrie Loranger · The Substack Notes Growth System: How to Turn 6–10 Notes a Day Into New Subscribers
She’s talking about Substack chat, where she runs polls and deeper discussions.
“It’s not just come to talk to me, it’s come to talk to us. Very often from my community, people collaborate with each other.”
Veronica Llorca-Smith 🍋 · Content Is the Gateway, Community Is the Anchor: Build a Substack People Stay For
She also gives her founding members a guest post or a Live slot so smaller creators get seen by her community.
“Substack is really all about interacting with people. You will have a tough time growing if you don’t make connections.”
Claudia Faith · Start From Zero: Grow Your First Substack Audience With Notes
“If you see somebody doing work you admire, Substack makes that person more accessible. Why not interact? Why not engage?”
Suzanne Taylor-King · The First Seven Days: Turn New Subscribers Into Returning Readers
If I were starting from zero, this is the one I wouldn’t skip. Pick 1 creator whose work you admire and reach out this week. A comment, a DM, a guest post idea or an invite to go live together.
5. Decide what you’d sell early
The creators earning from Substack thought about the offer before the audience was big.
“What do I write about? How do I grow my audience? Those are the wrong questions. The right question is what should I sell?”
Yana G.Y. · Start With the Offer: Build Your Substack Backwards From Revenue
“People never buy offers or challenges or masterminds. They buy the service, they buy the transformation.”
Ana Calin · Sell in Your Writing: Make Offers Without Sales Calls or Feeling Salesy
“You can make your Substack post a sales post without anyone noticing, by naturally writing about what you did.”
Benjamin Hies · Your Newsletter Is the Lead Magnet: Turn Substack Readers Into Consulting Clients
“Keep it short, especially for your first challenge, so you’re not overwhelmed and you could actually deliver on the promise.”
Danielle Desir Corbett · The Five-Day Challenge: Give Readers a Quick Win and Turn It Into Revenue
“Every time we hit a hundred new paid subscribers, we increase our prices by 30%.”
8fundraising by Nico & Ignacio · Resource Drops: Give Paid Readers Something They Can Use
6. People pay to belong
Paid subscribers stay for the people as much as the posts.
“People usually pay for your Substack to feel inspired, activated, educated, or part of a community.”
Claire Venus ✨ · Design Your Membership Tiers: Pricing, Value and Community on Substack
“We’re not just offering more content behind the paywall, but we’re creating a world that they want to belong to.”
Olivia Wickstrom · Keep Paid Members: Understand Cancellations and Give Readers Reasons to Renew
“The threshold for first becoming paid is much higher than staying paid.”
Robert Glazer · Give Free Readers a Reason to Upgrade: Why Guilt Fails and What Actually Converts
Where I’d start
Read the 6 again and they point the same way. Be clear about who you help. Sound like yourself. Talk to people. Build with other creators. Know what you’d offer. Give people somewhere to belong.
None of it needs a big audience. You can do all 6 from zero.
Every quote above comes from a full session at Substack Success Summit. You can see all 34 talk titles on the full agenda.
Substack Success Summit
November 11 to 13, 2026 · Online · Free · Starts 9am Eastern
Each day’s sessions are free to watch for 48 hours.
Already registered? You’re set. Share this with a creator you’d like to collaborate with. It’s a good opening line.
See you on November 11.
Liam Austin
Host of the Substack Success Summit
P.S. Reply 1-6 which is easiest for you right now? Tell me in the comments.






'5. Decide what you’d sell early', would probably be the easiest one for me. I've always reverse engineered any marketing efforts back to my end goal, i.e. the product I'm looking to sell.
I'm looking forward to Benjamin Hies session at the Substack Success Summit about how to use your newsletter as a leadmagnet. This'll be a great one for me as I'm new to Substack.
The growth number I watch most is how many of my posts get shared or restacked each week, since that's other people sending you readers.